Why Being “Compliant” Isn’t Enough to Fix Consent Problems

The consent management landscape in financial services often prioritises regulatory box-ticking over genuine customer empowerment. Many banks rely on consent banners that technically comply but manipulate user behavior, as seen in CaixaBank’s €6 million fine for failing to provide meaningful customer choice.

Three gaps drive this dysfunction: technical compliance without integration, where consent tools operate in silos disconnected from core systems; consent fatigue exploitation, where repeated requests push customers into hasty approvals; and dark patterns, where interface design nudges users toward sharing data under the guise of compliance.

The costs are significant. In 2024 alone, European financial institutions paid over €66 million in GDPR penalties, with consent-related violations growing fastest. Beyond fines, weak consent practices erode the digital trust that is critical to long-term banking relationships in an increasingly privacy-conscious market.

How Thinking Differently About Consent Can Solve the Problem

The solution lies in shifting consent management from a compliance burden to a strategic infrastructure capability. Forward-looking financial institutions recognise that strong consent governance not only ensures regulatory resilience but also drives customer trust and operational efficiency, creating real competitive advantage.

This requires positioning consent as a foundational data layer rather than a superficial compliance overlay. Effective systems must operate seamlessly across all touchpoints, provide granular user control, and integrate directly with core banking infrastructure to ensure consistent data handling.

The transformation rests on three pillars: architectural integration that embeds consent into core systems, experience-driven design that empowers users with transparent and intuitive choices, and operational automation that uses intelligent tools to maintain consent integrity across complex financial ecosystems.

Building Consent into Core Infrastructure

Consent management must evolve from surface-level compliance tools to a deeply embedded capability within banking infrastructure. Without this shift, institutions risk both regulatory penalties and loss of customer trust.

Key Shifts Required:‍

• Unified Data Architecture – Consent should not sit in silos. Event-driven systems ensure that any consent change immediately updates across all banking products loans, payments, wealth, and insurance removing gaps that create compliance risks.
• API-First Integration – Consent preferences must flow seamlessly between customer-facing apps and back-office systems. This ensures marketing tools, analytics platforms, and external providers stay aligned in real time, preventing unauthorised data use.
• Compliance-by-Design Frameworks – Consent validation needs to be built into every automated process. By making consent checks a prerequisite for data handling, banks create systematic safeguards against human error and regulatory breaches.

Why It Matters:
Traditional bolt-on consent tools operate in isolation, causing customer preferences to be inconsistently applied. Penalties faced by Spanish banks highlight the dangers of collecting consent but failing to honour it across integrated services.

Why Giving Customers Clear and Easy Control Boosts Trust

The most compliance-focused institutions often create the worst user experiences, leading to consent failures that undermine their regulatory objectives. Effective consent management requires abandoning manipulative design patterns in favour of transparent, empowering interfaces that genuinely serve customer interests.

Key Solutions:‍

• Eliminate Dark Patterns – Audit consent interfaces to remove manipulative designs such as pre-ticked boxes, complex opt-outs, or bundling services with marketing consent. Example: Zerodha builds trust through transparent, minimal data-sharing practices.
• Granular Control Mechanisms – Provide clear explanations of data use and allow selective consent for specific services. Ensure modifying consent is as easy as giving it.
• Progressive Consent Strategies – Reduce overload by asking for permissions contextually, at the moment of service use, rather than front-loading all requests at onboarding.

Intelligent Consent Lifecycle Management

Manual consent management leaves financial institutions vulnerable to compliance failures and inefficiencies. To address this, leading players are adopting intelligent automation that preserves consent integrity across complex ecosystems while reducing administrative burden.


‍Real-Time Consent Orchestration uses AI to continuously track customer preferences and flag potential violations before they occur. Integrated with marketing, CRM, and analytics platforms, it ensures consistent enforcement across all touchpoints.


‍Automated Compliance Monitoring applies machine learning to detect risks within business processes spotting manipulation, integration gaps, or emerging regulatory threats giving compliance teams proactive insights instead of reactive alerts.


Intelligent Documentation & Audit Trails create detailed records of every consent interaction, automatically generating reports and dashboards that meet regulatory standards while offering operational insights.


‍Vendor-Agnostic Integration enables flexible consent management that avoids lock-in, supports best-of-breed solutions, and adapts smoothly to evolving regulatory requirements.

How Better Consent Builds Trust, Cuts Costs, and Boosts Growth

In today’s privacy-conscious market, consent management is no longer just about compliance it’s a driver of trust, efficiency, and growth.

Competitive Advantages of Effective Consent Infrastructure‍

• Customer Trust Enhancement – Transparent consent builds loyalty, drives product adoption, and lowers acquisition costs through stronger trust and control.
• Operational Efficiency Gains – Automation cuts manual compliance work, reducing consent-related admin tasks by up to 72% and freeing teams for strategic focus.
• Regulatory Relationship Optimisation – Proactive consent governance positions institutions as trusted data stewards, influencing regulator priorities and approvals.
• Innovation Enablement – Strong consent foundations unlock advanced analytics, AI applications, and partnerships requiring robust privacy protection.

Institutions that treat consent as a strategic asset not a checkbox gain customer loyalty, regulatory goodwill, and a platform for innovation-driven growth.

How Fyscal Technologies Transform Consent Management

Fyscal Technologies partners with OneTrust to help financial institutions turn consent management from a compliance burden into a strategic advantage. Leveraging OneTrust’s UCPM (Universal Consent and Preference Management) platform, FT enables businesses to capture purpose-based user consents across websites, mobile apps, OTT, and Connected TV while centralising signals through API connectors. This ensures real-time propagation across banking and marketing systems. A unified consent and preference portal empowers customers with granular control, reduces opt-outs, and enhances user experience, while maintaining complete audit trails for regulatory audits.

Together, FT and OneTrust deliver intelligent compliance automation that streamlines multi-jurisdictional requirements, provides analytics on consent patterns, and flags risks with AI-powered monitoring. Their vendor-agnostic architecture allows institutions to integrate best-of-breed solutions without lock-in, building a scalable and future-ready consent infrastructure. The result is compliance by design that enhances trust, improves efficiency, and creates lasting competitive differentiation in a privacy-first financial ecosystem.

The Future Belongs to Consent Leaders

Financial institutions must decide whether to treat consent as a regulatory checkbox or as strategic infrastructure. Superficial compliance creates long-term vulnerabilities, while robust consent governance strengthens customer trust, improves efficiency, and unlocks measurable competitive advantages.

The path forward requires architectural integration, user-centric design, and intelligent automation. Institutions that embrace this shift build sustainable trust and resilience, while those that delay face rising regulatory risk, inefficiency, and competitive disadvantage in an increasingly privacy-conscious financial landscape.

‍

Ready to explore how comprehensive consent infrastructure can transform your business?

‍Book a Strategy Call →